RC RANDOM CHAOS

Quad9 Exits France Over Blocking Court Order

· via Hacker News

Original source

Quad9 (DNS Resolver) to Exit France

Hacker News →

Quad9, a Swiss nonprofit DNS resolver, will cease service in France starting November 24 after a French court ordered it to block DNS resolution for domains allegedly involved in copyright infringement related to sports broadcasts. The court imposed a daily financial penalty, reduced from an initial €580,000 lump sum.

Quad9 refuses to comply, arguing it’s technically impossible without abandoning core principles. The service operates free and without user registration or location tracking—features essential to their privacy mandate. Even geoIP-based blocking targeting only France would require tracking users by location, violating that commitment. Global blocking would apply French law to all internet users worldwide, setting a precedent for any nation to impose DNS restrictions globally. The company previously attempted similar blocking in Germany and faced additional fines when users circumvented it with VPNs, demonstrating the approach’s futility.

Quad9 contends the court fundamentally misunderstands DNS architecture and unfairly targets a neutral intermediary rather than addressing piracy at its source. The company views withdrawal as necessary to preserve internet principles rather than participate in what it sees as technically unworkable enforcement with dangerous precedential consequences.

Read the full article

Continue reading at Hacker News →

This is an AI-generated summary. Read the original for the full story.