RC RANDOM CHAOS

Fields Medalist Abandons Grading As AI Makes It Pointless

· via Hacker News

Original source

AI use leads UC Berkeley math professor to see 'no point' in grading homework

Hacker News →

Richard Borcherds, a Fields medalist at UC Berkeley, eliminated homework grading after observing that students routinely use AI to achieve top marks. Rather than pay staff to evaluate correctness, he shifted to awarding credit for completion alone—a system he acknowledges is inadequate but necessary given widespread student adoption of AI tools.

The decision reflects deeper anxieties within academia about the future viability of mathematics as a career. After OpenAI demonstrated AI solving a previously intractable mathematical problem, Borcherds expressed uncertainty about whether to encourage students to pursue the field. He noted that five years ago, mathematics seemed insulated from AI disruption, but current developments suggest the profession could face unprecedented challenges—the first time in mathematical history that a technology fundamentally outpaces human expertise.

UC Berkeley’s institutional response remains scattered. The Academic Senate encourages faculty to include AI policies in syllabi, but the campus has determined that existing detection tools are insufficient for standardized deployment. Individual instructors retain discretion over their AI policies, leaving no campus-wide consensus to guide the response to technological disruption that academic structures haven’t yet evolved to address.

Read the full article

Continue reading at Hacker News →

This is an AI-generated summary. Read the original for the full story.